Most Comfortable Heels in the USA for 2023
They say you should never compromise comfort for style, but let’s face it, high heels are not the most comfortable thing in the world.
Thankfully, shoe designers are making their shoes more comfortable than ever before, and you don’t have to invest in Louboutin’s or Jimmy Choo’s to put your best foot forward.
In this guide to the most comfortable heels in the USA, we’ll help you find the perfect pair for your ever-expanding footwear collection. Chic, stylish, and oh-so-comfortable shoes start right here!
Best Comfortable Heels in the USA
Here we go over the most comfortable heeled shoes for women in 2023 by type and style:
Most Comfortable High Heels
Winner: Selena High Heel Shoes
Pros:
- Ultimate comfortable occasion shoe.
- 3.5 inch heel.
- Pointed toe with a vamp that comes high up.
- Lamb leather upper and lining.
- Cushioned and arch supported insole.
- Non-slip sole.
- Handmade in Portugal by master shoemakers
- Available in a range of colors.
Most Comfortable Heels for Christmas Parties 2023
Winner: Ava Low Heel Leather Shoes
Pros:
- Elegant kitten heel shoe.
- Extra width and volume in the toe area.
- Soft leather.
- Cushioned and arch supported insole.
- Non-slip sole.
- Handmade in Portugal by master shoemakers
- Available in a range of colors.
- Also available in suede.
Most Comfortable Heels for Wedding Guests 2023
Winner: Emily II Black Leather High Heels
Pros:
- Luxuriously soft shoe.
- Perfect for standing all day.
- 3.5 inch heel
- Lamb leather upper and lining
- Cushioned and arch supported insole
- Non-slip sole
- Handmade in Portugal by master shoemakers
- Available in a range of colors
Most Comfortable Block Heels 2023
Winner: Sara Mid Heel Shoe
Pros:
- Comfortable mid heel shoe.
- HIdden stretch panel in the bunion area for comfort.
- Kid leather lining.
- Cushioned and arch supported insole.
- Non-slip sole.
- Handmade in Portugal by master shoemakers
- Available in a range of colors.
- Also available in leather.
Most Comfortable Kitten Heels 2023
Winner: Ava Low Heel Leather Shoes
Pros:
- Elegant kitten heel shoe.
- Extra width and volume in the toe area.
- Soft leather.
- Cushioned and arch supported insole.
- Non-slip sole.
- Handmade in Portugal by master shoemakers
- Available in a range of colors.
- Also available in suede.
Most Comfortable Heeled Sandals 2023
Winner: SUSAi Black Leather Heels
Pros:
- Versatile heeled shoe
- 3 inch block heel
- Pointed toe with a vamp that comes high up
- Kid leather upper and lining
- Cushioned and arch supported insole
- Non-slip sole
- Handmade in Portugal by master shoemakers
- Available in a range of colors
Most Comfortable Heels for Beginners 2023
Winner: Sara Mid Heel Shoe
Pros:
- Comfortable mid heel shoe.
- HIdden stretch panel in the bunion area for comfort.
- Kid leather lining.
- Cushioned and arch supported insole.
- Non-slip sole.
- Handmade in Portugal by master shoemakers
- Available in a range of colors.
- Also available in leather.
Most Comfortable Black Strappy Heels 2023
Winner: Suki Black Leather Heels
Pros:
- Versatile heeled shoe
- 3 inch block heel
- Pointed toe with a vamp that comes high up
- Kid leather upper and lining
- Cushioned and arch supported insole
- Non-slip sole
- Handmade in Portugal by master shoemakers
- Available in a range of colors
Most Comfortable Nude Heels 2023
Winner: Selena High Heel Shoes
Pros:
- Ultimate comfortable occasion shoe.
- 3.5 inch heel.
- Pointed toe with a vamp that comes high up.
- Lamb leather upper and lining.
- Cushioned and arch supported insole.
- Non-slip sole.
- Handmade in Portugal by master shoemakers
- Available in a range of colors.
Most Comfortable Heels for Work 2023
Winner: Sophia Black Leather Court Shoe
Pros:
- Perfect work shoe.
- Classic, timeless court shoe.
- 3 inch heel and 0.5 inch platform.
- Kid leather upper and lining.
- Cushioned and arch supported insole.
- Non-slip sole.
- Handmade in Portugal by master shoemakers
- Available in a range of colors.
Can You Buy Comfortable Heels?
Whether you are looking for comfortable heels for work, play, or a special occasion such as your wedding day, there are certain things you should look out for when trying them for size.
The world’s most comfortable high heels will have:
- Cushioned arch supporting insoles (for optimal arch support)
- Luxuriously soft padding to relieve pressure on the ball of your foot
- Carefully placed touch points to ensure a snug fit from heel to toe.
Without these components, your shoes will not be comfortable, and prolonged wear will cause you nothing but pain.
Heel height is another thing to consider when looking for comfort. While there is nothing sexier than towering 10cm stilettos, they might not be the best choice for a long day at the office or an even longer night out on the town. But alas, kitten heels don’t do it for many.
A great compromise is the platform heel. With elevation at both the front and back of the shoe, platform heels are much less demanding on the feet than stilettos, yet they provide the height that many of us crave (and need).
If you feel the pinch across the front of your toes when wearing heels, look for a pair with a wide toe box. They are much more comfortable than pointy toe designs, and if you have wider feet, they’ll provide the additional space you need.
Finally, when shopping for comfortable heels, make sure you buy the correct size. Sizes vary from designer to designer, and if your heels are too small, you may experience cramps, sores, and blisters. Wherever possible, try them on before you buy, and if in doubt, go up half a size.
Wearing High Heels with Bunions
Can you wear high heels if you have bunions? Yes, you can, many designers make heels for women with bunions, but not all off-the-shelf shoes will be a comfortable fit. Wide-fitting shoes with plenty of space around the toe box are the best option. Avoid heels with strappy fronts as they could put extra pressure on sensitive bunions.
How High is Too High?
When it comes to comfortable high heels, heel height is everything. The higher they are, the more pressure they will put on the ball of your foot and cause discomfort. 3-inch and 4-inch stilettos remain the most popular choice in the USA today, but mid-heels, typically measuring 2.5 inches, are ideal for all-day wear.
Kitten heels are making a comeback too, so if you're yet to try out these lower heel designs, it’s time to give them a go. They are the most comfortable heels of all and have just the right height to elevate your everyday looks.
How to Walk in High Heels
Walking in high heels is not as easy as it looks. If you are yet to master the art, start with a pair of platforms or shoes with block heels. With the additional support of a wide platform or chunky heel, you’ll be less likely to lose your balance. You’ll be strutting your stuff up and down the office in no time.
Top Tips on Shopping for Comfortable Shoes
Shopping for comfortable shoes online is not always the best option. Especially if you are between sizes or not used to wearing shoes with high heels. Trying shoes in-store is a much better option. Here are our top tips:
- Buy heels in the afternoon: Our feet swell up throughout the day and are often at their largest in the late afternoon, making this the best time to try on any new shoes. If you are looking for comfort, avoid shopping for shoes in the morning.
- Wear the correct hosiery when trying on heels: If you are buying comfortable heels for your wedding or another special occasion, and you intend to wear tights, stockings, or trendy knee-high socks, take them with you when you go to try on your new shoes to ensure an accurate fit.
- Don’t compromise on comfort for style: If the heels you try on are not comfortable straight away, don’t rely on them breaking in after a few days. Chances are they won’t, and you’ll be stuck with shoes that hurt.
- Take care of your feet: You can buy the best quality shoes in the world, but if you don’t look after your feet, you’ll never achieve the level of comfort you are looking for. Regular massage, stretching of the Achilles tendon, and exercises such as ankle circles will keep your feet in top condition and help you avoid the pain often associated with wearing high heels.
Related:
- Best Shoes for Swollen Feet
- Comfortable Mother of the Bride Shoes
- Best Shoes for Bunions
- Best Shoes for Plantar Fasciitis
Conclusion
Is there such as thing as comfortable high heels? Yes, there is, but as we mentioned above, you should try various styles to find the right shoes for your feet. Arch support, cushioning around the toes, and heel height all play a role in overall comfort, as does the quality of the shoe.
A chunky heel will always be more comfortable than a slim stiletto, and if you are worried about losing your balance, block heels are the best choice for you.
If you have any questions, contact us at hello@callashoes.com or leave your questions in the comments.
Author: Jennifer Bailey
Jennifer Bailey is the founder of Calla Shoes, and has suffered from bunions for over 20 years. She specialises in footwear designed for people with foot problems, including bunions, plantar fasciitis, and swollen feet. Linkedin | Twitter
